I've been paying for pay-per-views since they've been available to buy. Forty years in, you start to develop a feel for these things — when a card is cooking, when it's going through the motions, when the company is asking you to invest in someone they haven't quite sold yet. Tonight's Backlash had all three.
Before I get into the matches, a word about the format. The first two bouts ran on what I assume was the standard ESPN broadcast deal, and then the rest of the show lived behind a $29.99 paywall on the ESPN app. That's the first time I've ever paid that particular thirty dollars, and I want to be clear about something up front: I got my money's worth tonight, but TKO and WWE shouldn't get to claim that as a win. We'll get to that.
Here's what I saw.
Seth Rollins vs. Bron Breakker
Seth Rollins looked as good as I have ever seen him in a wrestling ring tonight. There were spots in this match that belong on any career highlight reel — the turnbuckle powerbomb coast-to-coast where Seth absolutely committed, the short-arm clothesline he caught Bron with on the way up, and the superplex sequence that Bron reversed into a Falcon Arrow. That last one was as crisp as I have ever seen the move executed. Seth essentially set up his own combo and Bron flipped it on him. Beautiful.
But here's the thing — I didn't like what I saw from Bron tonight. He looked flat. The Frankensteiners are impressive, the lineage is real, the tools are obvious. What's missing is the mid-match charisma that makes you believe he's a monster heel. There was a moment where Seth, on his back, slapped Bron across the face. Man to man, that read as disrespectful to me — and in that warrior culture, I'm fairly certain that was a shoot slap. I think Seth was telling Bron to focus. Look at me. Seth was working. Bron was floating.
The most interesting thing in this match, though, wasn't the wrestling. It was Paul Heyman's face during one of Seth's Shining Wizards. For a second, I'd swear Heyman remembered that Seth Rollins used to be Tyler Black. And I'm wondering if that's the door this storyline is opening — that Heyman wanted Tyler Black, not the polished Seth Freakin' Rollins, and he's just realized Tyler Black is back on the menu. That's a lane I'd love to see them take.
As for Bron, he might be due for one of those Bob Holly summer tours. He needs to figure out who he is, and I don't think "The Vision" gimmick is the answer. WWE is asking us to buy aggression that may not actually be there — covered up, maybe, by talent and lineage. He's going to have to find it for real before this works.
Sami Zayn vs. Trick Williams
This one had a little Jackass energy to it — shades of Sami's match with Johnny Knoxville. Trick is raw. There's a lot of in-ring work he still needs to put in, and Sami knows it. You could see Sami staying small and giving Trick room to shine, never overshadowing him. That's a veteran move, and it paid off.
Because boy, does Trick have an aura. He looked phenomenal. Everything he did worked. He's got major heel presence — the kind where you just want to see somebody bring him down to size — and that's exactly the energy a champion should be projecting. I'm bullish on Trick.
I'm a little concerned for Sami, though. A year ago he had momentum and a spring in his step. Tonight he looked a half-step off. Could be the layoff. Could be he was just having a night. Could be he's not feeling it. Could be a work — and that's the thing about Sami Zayn, you can never quite tell. But something was different, and it's worth watching.
A Brief Word About the Thirty Dollars
Before I get to the rest of the card, I have to address this. I'm a lifelong wrestling fan. I was a fan during the Bloodline. I was a fan during the Gobbledy Gooker era. I'll be a fan when whatever comes next comes next. The business is changing, and I get it — there's a certain amount of my disposable income that WWE is going to command every year, and as I get older and lean further into my hobbies, that share is probably going to grow.
But I'm not going to sit here and endorse TKO's money-grabbing approach to the product. The fate of professional wrestling, in a real sense, is in the hands of Paul Levesque and Nick Khan. And honestly? If it came down to it, I think Triple H could probably take Nick Khan in a cage match. So I feel okay about it. But fans need to watch their hearts on their wallets. The thirty dollars was worth it tonight. That doesn't mean the model is.
Danhausen, Kit Wilson, and The Miz
Going in, I think we all expected the CM Punkhausen segment to be carried by Punk. That was not the case. This was the first PLE my wife Jenn has sat through with me in some time — she wanted to pay attention because she knew I was writing about it — and far and away, this was her favorite part of the night. She became ensorcelled with Danhausen. I do not use that word lightly. I myself was cursed in the most pleasant way.
Danhausen is great. He reminds me of a vaudevillian Orange Cassidy. He reminds me of the grandkid of that old vampire grandpa who used to introduce horror movies on TV in the eighties and nineties. He's nice. He's evil. He works in the ring. He's funny without trying. Jenn was charmed front to finish. So was I.
But the real story here is Kit Wilson and Mike Mizanin. I love this mentorship — both in kayfabe and in real life. Mike is the perfect veteran to teach Kit how to turn, in every sense of that word. Kayfabe-wise, Mike can teach Kit how to turn chicken excrement into chicken salad — and we all know which phrase he'd actually use. There's an art to that, and the Miz has spent twenty years mastering it. Watching him pass it down is one of the more genuinely encouraging things I've seen in a while.
There were five matches on this card. This one belonged on the show. In these dog days of professional wrestling, this is where the magic happens — the experimentation, the weirdness, the willingness to let a character like Danhausen exist on a major card. This is why I love the WWE.
Iyo Sky vs. Asuka
You could see it the moment Iyo walked out. Something was heavy. She wasn't joyful — she was focused, grim, locked in. I haven't been plugged into the IWC the last couple of months — I've been head-down on a few business projects — so I don't know exactly where Asuka is from a career standpoint, whether there's a return to Japan being discussed, or whether contract talks aren't going the way she'd like. But something was different about how Iyo carried that match.
Here's what I will say, and I'll say it again for the people in the back: those two women are two of the greatest pound-for-pound professional wrestlers in the history of the business. Come at me. Tonight they put on a clinic. The spot where Iyo blocked Asuka's poison mist with the tablet was inventive, the finish was earned, and the whole thing was crisp from bell to bell.
If that was Asuka's last match in the WWE, she is a first-ballot Hall of Famer. Period. No conversation needed.
In a greater sense — and this is the part that hit me afterwards — twenty years ago the standard for women's matches in this company was a bra and panties match. Twenty years. These two women are astounding athletes, serious warriors, and trailblazers in every meaningful way. Whatever happens next for either of them, they should be remembered as the people who helped change what this industry will accept as women's wrestling.
Roman Reigns vs. Jacob Fatu
Roman was Roman. Flawless. At this point in his career, Roman Reigns is on my Mount Rushmore — and I'll defend that. Nobody has done what he did with the Bloodline. Nobody has had a character arc like that. And let's not forget — he spent years getting booed off Vince's pay-per-views before he turned it around. That kind of reinvention, in the most public way possible, is one of the great accomplishments in modern wrestling. I am a huge Roman fan.
I want to believe in Jacob Fatu. I really do. He's big, he's agile, he's gritty, he's nasty, he's tough. The Tongan Death Grip is a magnificent callback — Haku is, pound-for-pound, considered the toughest man in any locker room he ever set foot in, and Jacob carrying that into his moveset means something. That part is great.
But — and this is hard to say — I don't buy Jacob the way I bought Stone Cold. I don't buy him the way I buy Oba Femi as a titan ruling over the world. The aggression isn't paying off for me yet. I think the issue is one of pacing and character maturity. Cody Rhodes has talked about Arn Anderson making a promo out of taking off his shirt, taking off his watch, doing everything slow — letting the moment marinate. That savoring quality is what Jacob is missing. He's all gas, no brakes. Maybe what he needs to learn is how to turn it down a little so the explosions actually land.
Roman wins clean and keeps his title. I think we may see Jacob go away for a stretch, and honestly that might be the best thing for him. Come back when there's a clear path and a more mature character. The tools are all there. He just hasn't grown into them yet.
What I'm Walking Away With
It was a strong card. The in-ring work was solid front to back. But here's where my head is at:
Bron Breakker is the wrestler I'm most worried about. I just didn't see it tonight, and I have real concerns about whether he can find the character WWE needs him to be. Jacob Fatu is going to be fine, but he probably needs to cool off and come back hungrier. Asuka may have just given us her last great American moment, and if she did, the legacy is sealed.
But the thing I keep coming back to — the thing that justified the thirty dollars all by itself — is Danhausen and the Minihausens, the Miz and Kit Wilson, the whole strange beautiful interlude in the middle of the night. We need more of that in wrestling. The big matches will always be there. The strangeness is what we have to fight for.
Suffice it to say, I'll be watching what they do with all of it.